Table of Contents
- Know Your Legal Rights When You Share Fault in a Texas Personal Injury Case
- What Is Modified Comparative Fault in Texas?
- Common Situations Where Fault Is Shared in Texas Personal Injury Cases
- How Texas Assigns Fault Percentages
- The 51% Bar Rule — Texas’s Critical Threshold
- Why Comparative Fault Cases Are Challenging
- How Ried Pecina Trial Lawyers Protects Your Rights
- What You Should Do if Fault Is Disputed
- Free Consultation — Call (210) 893-0000 Now!
Know Your Legal Rights When You Share Fault in a Texas Personal Injury Case
If you’ve been injured in Texas—whether in a car accident, trucking crash, slip and fall, or other injury—and the other party says you share some blame, don’t assume you can’t recover damages. Under Texas’s modified comparative fault law, you may still be entitled to compensation for medical bills, lost wages, pain, suffering, and other losses.
Even when fault is disputed, the law lets injured people seek recovery as long as their fault is less than 51%. This is why insurance companies try to increase your fault percentage. Every point they add reduces what they must pay.
Having an experienced Texas personal injury lawyer can mean the difference between getting nothing and receiving the compensation you deserve.
What Is Modified Comparative Fault in Texas?
Not all accidents have a clear, single cause. In many Texas personal injury cases, more than one person contributes. This includes actions taken or failures to act. It’s common in car accidents, trucking crashes, workplace injuries, and slip-and-fall claims.
Texas law handles this with the modified comparative fault rule, also called the 51% Bar Rule. This rule decides if you can recover compensation and how much, even if you share fault.
Under modified comparative fault, each party gets a fault percentage based on the evidence. Your compensation is reduced by your fault percentage. If you are 51% or more at fault, Texas law bars you from recovering damages.
This rule greatly impacts your case outcome. Insurance companies try hard to raise your fault percentage. The more they can blame you, the less they pay—or they pay nothing at all. For this reason, fault disputes are central in Texas personal injury cases.
Common Situations Where Fault Is Shared in Texas Personal Injury Cases
Understanding how shared fault works is important when pursuing a personal injury claim. Many accidents involve multiple people who contributed to the injury.
Here are some common examples:
-
Car Accidents: One driver follows too closely while the other suddenly turns without signaling. This often causes crashes where both drivers share blame.
-
Slip and Fall Injuries: A person distracted by their phone slips on a wet or hazardous floor. The property owner might share fault for unsafe conditions.
-
Pedestrian Accidents: A pedestrian runs unexpectedly into traffic while a driver is speeding. Both may be responsible for the accident.
In such cases, fault is rarely clear cut. Texas law requires assigning percentages of fault to each party involved.
These fault percentages reduce the amount of compensation each injured party can receive. The higher your fault, the lower your payout.
That is why accurate fault determination is critical in Texas personal injury cases.
Having an experienced Texas personal injury lawyer helps ensure fault is fairly assigned. A skilled attorney protects your right to maximum compensation.
How Texas Assigns Fault Percentages
When multiple parties share fault, Texas law assigns a percentage of responsibility to each person. Judges and juries base this on the evidence presented.
Your total damages get reduced according to your share of fault. The more responsible you are, the less you can recover.
For example:
- Driver A tailgated and is 60% at fault.
- Driver B made a dangerous, unsignaled turn and is 40% at fault.
If a passenger has $10,000 in damages, Driver A’s insurance pays $6,000. Driver B’s insurance pays $4,000.
Each party pays their fair share based on their assigned fault percentage. This system ensures damages are distributed fairly when multiple people cause an accident.
The 51% Bar Rule — Texas’s Critical Threshold
Texas law uses a modified comparative fault system to decide if and how much you can recover after an accident.
You can recover damages if your fault is 50% or less. The law allows you to collect compensation even if you share some blame.
However, if you are 51% or more at fault, you cannot recover anything. Texas law bars your claim completely once you pass this threshold.
For example, if Driver B is 40% at fault and suffers $50,000 in damages, they can recover $30,000. The compensation reduces by their 40% fault.
On the other hand, if Driver A is 60% at fault with the same damages, they recover nothing. Their claim is barred by law.
Insurance companies know this rule well. They often try to push your fault percentage above 50%. If they succeed, they avoid paying you anything.
That’s why it is crucial to have an experienced Texas personal injury lawyer. We fight to keep your fault percentage low and maximize your recovery.
Why Comparative Fault Cases Are Challenging
Disputed-fault cases are some of the toughest personal injury claims in Texas. Insurance companies aggressively defend their bottom line.
Even if they cannot deny your claim outright, they work hard to reduce your settlement amount. Their main tactic is to increase your percentage of fault. The higher your fault, the less money you receive.
To achieve this, insurance companies:
- Send adjusters to collect statements. They look for anything that can be used against you.
- Hire accident reconstruction experts. These experts often support the insurer’s position.
- Exploit legal loopholes and technicalities. They try to prove you bear more responsibility than you actually do.
Without a skilled Texas personal injury attorney, you face a serious disadvantage. The insurance company’s tactics can overwhelm you.
A knowledgeable lawyer will scrutinize every claim and fight these unfair tactics. They work to keep your fault percentage as low as possible and maximize your compensation.
How Ried Pecina Trial Lawyers Protects Your Rights
At Ried Pecina Trial Lawyers, we know Texas injury law and the tactics insurance companies use. We build cases with strong evidence and expert testimony to protect you from unfair blame.
Our San Antonio legal team will:
- Conduct an in-depth accident investigation to determine the true cause.
- Interview witnesses and preserve surveillance footage.
- Work with medical and accident experts to support your claim.
- Challenge exaggerated fault assignments from insurance companies.
- Negotiate for maximum settlement value or take your case to court if needed.
We do not back down from complex, high-stakes personal injury disputes — especially when the other side tries to shift blame.
What You Should Do if Fault Is Disputed
If the other party or their insurance company claims you share fault in the accident, act quickly to protect your rights. Taking immediate, smart steps can make a big difference in your case’s outcome.
Follow these important steps carefully:
- Do not admit fault or apologize, even casually. Any admission can be used to reduce or deny your claim. Stay calm and avoid blaming yourself.
- Do not give a recorded statements without consulting a personal injury attorney. Insurance adjusters often use these statements against you. Let your lawyer guide your communication.
- Collect as much evidence as possible at the scene. Take clear photos and videos of the accident, damages, and any hazards. Get contact information from all witnesses. This evidence strengthens your case.
- Seek medical attention right away, even if injuries seem minor. Follow your doctor’s instructions fully and keep detailed medical records. Your health and medical proof are vital for your claim.
- Contact Ried Pecina Trial Lawyers immediately before you speak with insurance companies. Our accident team knows the tactics insurers use and will protect your interests from the start.
Starting your case early helps us build a strong defense against unfair fault claims. The faster we act, the better we can fight for your maximum compensation.
Free Consultation — Call (210) 893-0000 Now!
Don’t let an insurance company decide your future. If you’ve been injured in Texas and fault is being debated, you may still be entitled to substantial compensation under the modified comparative fault law.
Call Ried Pecina Trial Lawyers today at (210) 893-0000 or fill out our online contact form to schedule your free case evaluation. We only get paid if we win for you.
